The Emerging Shift from Charity to Capital
Investment in Africa
The global economic recession isn’t going away any
time soon. It will likely be worse than 2008 with the Euro debt
hanging over us, the U.S. slow recovery, and China’s growth also
slowing (but still strong). There is no magic bullet for what is
ailing the world and the pain will be felt for a long time.
However, just because there are economic crises
doesn’t mean there isn’t money and resources available to invest in
Africa.
There are many people and organizations sitting on
cash and resources looking for solid opportunities in which to
invest. I think of a recent story by the Associated Press on Ajay
Piramal, an Indian billionaire, who is sitting on cash from sales of
his pharmaceutical firm because he cannot find good investments in
India. His issue was transparency in large transactions, which is a
wake-up call for anyone looking for an investor. Transparency is
important.
Another issue is identifying these opportunities and
connecting investors to good investments. In the case of African
SMEs, the Missing Middle Initiative of the World Economic Forum (WEF),
and originally spearheaded by the South African Chamber of Commerce
in America (SACCI), demonstrated that there were many SME
institutions, but still funding of SMEs was a gap in the ecosystem.
Many more organizations are rising to fill this
void. Funding and capacity organizations, like GroFin, provide both
funding and technical capacity support to SMEs. Standard Bank has
developed innovative solutions targeting the SME market recently and
found growing success. Nexii has created an exchange board called iX
for impact investment in sustainable social enterprises whether
for-profit or non-profit. And there is even the first seed
investment fund for tech entrepreneurs in Africa launching in 2012
called the Savannah Seed Investment Fund.
Some of these platforms, like iX and Savannah Seed
Investment Fund, can be used by investors to identify good
investment opportunities with transparency. iX works like a stock
exchange (with many other types of offerings) so individuals even
with small budgets can easily purchase stocks in an enterprise.
Another platform is VC4Africa, which connects entrepreneurs and
investors focused on opportunities in Africa.
This space will continue to evolve aggressively over
the next 10 years, so this should stimulate growth of capital
investment into African enterprises at all levels. However, there is
still a huge pool of funds allocated elsewhere both in formal and
informal structures – charity. This is where the conversation gets a
little sensitive for some in the audience.
The debate over trade versus aid has reached new
levels. I can say I am definitely for this movement. However, it is
not to say that some charity and aid work is not highly beneficial.
There are thousands of great NGOs doing necessary work and impactful
work, so we don’t want to take away from that work.
On the other hand, there is a lot of traditional
models of charity that haven’t been revamped in decades, asking us
to help with the same problems. I am going to personalize this now,
so that you don’t think I am just an outside observer.
I grew up in a very giving family. My parents still
give more than almost anyone I know, both in their personal time and
resources.
When I was in my twenties and early 30s like many
Americans, I saw the commercials on TV for poor children around the
world and I sent monthly donations to assist the children and got
progress reports. This is a "good" thing to do.
However, when I began doing research on Africa and
subsequently moved to South Africa, I began to realize that this was
not the "right" thing to do. Each year funds are sent to help
children but creating economically sustainable communities is not a
priority, so the communities become dependent instead of
interdependent, or independent, and able to help others. Many of
these children can end up on the streets when they become adults
because there is not enough gainful employment or academic
opportunities for them.
When I came to South Africa, this is the very
scenario I was hoping to correct. I started working with a group of
homeless teenage boys in Sandton, South Africa. They used to live
and camp out next to the McDonald’s in Sandton in the lot that was
replaced by a large office complex at the corner across from
Investec.
They obviously needed clothing, food, and housing,
but I wasn’t naïve enough to think that doing just that would solve
their problems. In fact, I had to find another solution as it was
difficult in winter to find space for older teenage boys in the
local shelters. I got so frustrated because, even with my
connections, I couldn’t seem to find something temporary with the
goal of getting them in school and working.
Then, one day a friend from church suggested having
the boys make custom cards to earn income. At first, I wasn’t too
excited about the idea but after a few professionals said they liked
the cards I figured there was enough of a market at least to support
my small group of teens, which now included a few young girls.
It ran well as long as I was fully involved. The
teens were required to come to school two to three days a week. We
held it at the Sandton Public Library thanks to the generosity of
the Head Branch Librarian and I was the teacher, seeing as my
Master’s degree is in education and I had some experience working
with at-risk youth. If they came to school, they were allowed to
work and earn money.
In two weeks, several of my boys got off the street,
paying for their own place, food, clothes, and transport. I then
knew this was the "right" direction. Out of this experience, I still
work on developing for-profit ventures that are both economically
sustainable and address social issues because through this process
we can break poverty and dependency.
But I can thankfully say that I am not the only one.
People who have been working in development are getting tired of
seeing the same problems. In an interview with Richard Schroeder,
President of First Step in Sierra Leone, he shared that he had
worked in microfinance for 15 years and didn’t feel it adequately
addressed poverty. Instead, he and his team developed the first
special economic zone in Sierra Leone which is bringing local jobs,
economic opportunity to communities across Sierra Leone, and a
platform that Sierra Leone can use to attract foreign businesses and
investors. And First Step happens to be a for-profit subsidiary of
World Hope International (WHI), a Christian humanitarian agency.
They have successfully synergized the strengths and mandate of a
non-profit with a for-profit venture that can stimulate economic
sustainability throughout Sierra Leone and for WHI as well.
On another front, many non-profit organizations are
feeling the economic pinch not only because of the economic crisis
but also competition. Everywhere you look, a new non-profit needing
support is coming to tap the same pool of resources already out
there.
Also, givers are looking more strategically at their
giving. This is where the wave of capital investment will come from.
As traditional givers decide to become investors, the capital
investment pool for Africa, and other emerging regions, will grow
dramatically and quickly.
Imagine trillions of dollars flowing to capital
investment from this resource pool. It can be scary for NGOs not on
the right side of the equation, but promising for everyone else.
By Lauri Elliott, Source: Afribiz
Importing Food from Africa to the USA
Before doing business in a foreign country, it is
critical that you know all that you can about the market. This
valuable bit of information will undoubtedly save you time, money,
and energy. Selva Pillay, with GLX Delivery Solutions, found this
out the hard way when he moved from South Africa to the United
States and brought with him spectacular arts and crafts to sell in
the American market, "I felt that I could bring products here and
market them to the US market. I was very confident at that time. I
felt that whatever we brought to the US would be a success. Not
knowing this market, not knowing what they need, (and) how it works,
was a huge setback for me."
After experimenting with arts and crafts, Pillay
decided that he would form his business around importing and selling
foods from Africa. This time, before he shipped any food to the
United States, he did research to find out what kinds of items would
be well received. After Pillay decided what he wanted to sell, he
targeted the vegan/vegetarian market in California, where he is
based.
Pillay says that he was urged by some to go straight
to Trader Joes, Whole Foods, and other large national chains.
Instead, he started contacting mom and pop stores to carry his
products. This was a tactical move that he made in order to build up
a reputation and credibility for his products before entering larger
markets. Once his products became popular, he was able to branch out
to some of the larger local grocery stores like Farmer Joe’s and
Andronico’s in San Francisco.
"I started working with the medium and larger sized
chain stores," Pillay explains. "Then, I started focusing on the
very large independents, like Rainbow Grocery in San Francisco. [The
trade is] a very close knit family. They know each other and they
know their competitors. Once they realize that the competition has
the product, they want to carry it as well. Using that method, I was
able to get into bigger areas where I had people like Costco and
Whole Foods looking at the product."
Aside from finding someone to carry your product,
there are numerous other obstacles that you will face when importing
foods, or other goods, to the United States. These issues can range
from freight costs and clearing customs to dealing with the FDA and
getting their approval. Pillay says that this initial stress can pay
off in the long run though, "The work is really mindboggling in the
initial stages, but what you must understand is the US has a
fantastic system of doing things correctly the first time and then
replicating the process. If you are prepared to invest in those
hardships, in the first instance, once you reach the stage where
your product becomes known in this marketplace and it’s a regular
selling product, it becomes a business that runs on its own. The
challenge is that you have do it correctly initially."
And finally, Pillay says, "It’s about 80% research
and 20% selling your product in the market. It’s easy to sell
product here because the market’s always engaged in new products…
they’re always looking at new opportunities… The struggle is for you
to understand that it (your product) has to stand apart from the
competition. They’re not looking for mediocre, they’re looking for
the best of the best."
Source image by Calliope, Source: Afribiz
The Rise of New Wealth in Africa
As I completed this article, the Economist wrote a
story retracting its "hopeless" tag on Africa and said it is the
"hopeful" continent. The article also shared that Oprah Winfrey
(worth $3 billion) is no longer the richest person of African
descent, but Aliko Dangote (worth $13.8 billion) of Nigeria is. How
things have changed. I think this is a perfect introduction to this
piece.
In 2011, ten of the richest Africans have a combined
worth of approximately $47 billion. While this represents stores of
wealth and not annual income, it is still staggering that only a few
people have wealth greater than annual revenue generated in many
countries in the world. There isn’t a problem that individuals have
accumulated such wealth, actually. It’s a good sign that Africa is
on the move.
In fact, it is not only a few Africans on the
continent who are becoming wealthier. The African middle class
(including lower middle and high middle) numbered about 313 million,
or 34.3% of Africa’s population, in 2010, according to the African
Development Bank (AfDB). This represents almost three times the
number of people that were considered middle class in 1980.
The challenge still remains that the economic growth
that fueled economies globally in the last decade was by and large
unequal – the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer (or
going nowhere). This unfortunately is also the case in many parts of
Africa.
While there are many reasons for this, some are
rooted in the weaknesses in the current free market/capitalist
economic models. I have suggested before that free market/capitalist
economic models need to evolve to provide economic opportunity for
all. Current models still too often allow a few to control markets
and opportunities. However, redistribution of, or state-dominated,
wealth is not the answer, creation of new wealth is.
So, where does all this new wealth come from? First,
I want to return to other pieces that I did in this series,
"Emerging Shifts in Africa." The increased world population and
increased consumption will make commodities – mineral, metal, and
agriculture – extremely valuable. Because Africa has an abundance of
natural resources, proper strategy and implementation should make
sure that Africa develops much more of this wealth. While Africa,
because of both internal and external influences, has not lived up
to its potential, better overall governance, more savvy leadership,
more vocal and active citizens, etc. are increasingly directing
Africa to the right course. However, the next ten years will be
volatile not just for Africa, but for the world.
Next we can look to two key population segments in
Africa that have heretofore been marginalized – youth and indigenous
nations. African youth is one of the fastest growing population
segments and represents a huge consumer market. Second, indigenous
nations sit on a lot of the arable land for agriculture and from
which minerals are extracted (this varies from country to country).
Businesses will eventually seek out the opportunities represented by
these groups, and like natural resources, if the human capital is
developed, the wealth will follow.
Also, technology and innovation will have a lot to
do with it. As ICT infrastructure continues to grow on the
continent, people will be able to tap into more knowledge,
connections, and resources to improve their livelihoods. To catalyze
this potential, researchers, like Lucienne Abrahams and Mark Burke
of the University of Witwatersrand in South Africa, are informing
government policy by urging government to support the potential in
"home" economies.
The ICT sector will bring new wealth to more people
in the industry as we have seen in Western markets, but more
importantly ICT is one of the enablers for creating and
collaborating on new innovations. It still sticks out in my mind how
through crowdsourcing with the public, a Canadian company discovered
minerals worth several hundred million on land they already owned.
Then, there are intangible assets, including
intellectual property. Intangible assets are the fastest growing
asset class. Companies actually account for intangible assets in
their book value. On the S&P 500, the intangible value of companies
as a percentage of market capitalization has doubled every ten years
while tangible book value decreased (based on 2005 data).
Africa has not been sufficiently represented in
building wealth from intangible assets as Western markets.
Unfortunately, most countries are not well-diversified within
primary sectors like mining and agriculture, much less secondary
(e.g., manufacturing), tertiary (e.g., services), and quaternary
(e.g., intellectual) sectors.
There is a lot of innovation in mobile and web
platforms emerging across the continent. However, South Africa is
the leading country on the continent for secondary, tertiary, and
quaternary sectors. All of these sectors beyond primary are
diversified. Recent examples include a new affordable and
modularized defense airplane called the AHRLAC; solar-powered,
containerized, connected school by Samsung; and a portable waste
plant.
More broadly, Africans are excellent at what is
called "work-around" innovations. They solve problems with what they
have access to and what they can afford. One of our clients in
Africa purchased a used incubator from the United States for about
$20,000, which is beyond what most small-scale African farmers can
afford. A Kenyan farmer developed an affordable small incubator for
the small-scale farmer market. This innovation will help small-scale
farmers increase the production of eggs and chickens to serve local
markets, which have sufficient demand, and thereby increasing their
incomes. As more of these "work-around" innovations become
commercialized, there will be an increase in wealth as well.
Also, Africans already hold a lot of intangible
assets, even intellectual property, in their indigenous knowledge
and heritage. What has been difficult is protecting it and
understanding the value it brings to others outside of African
communities, so as not to be exploited and be able to develop the
value into a commercialized product.
The sources of new wealth already mentioned are
logical observations, leading to a new future in Africa if the
continent stays on track. But there are other sources of new wealth
– a change in what is considered most valuable and the ability to
trade in concepts – that will re-map the entire globe . They will
shape the "New Africa" more than any other source of wealth.
An example of a change in what is considered
valuable is the carbon market. The issues of climate change are
dominating global discussions and governance, resulting in the
development of the concept of carbon offsets – those who create too
many carbons pay those who offset the carbon gases.
Africans manage a good portion of the natural
resources that support the environment in which all people live. As
we speak, projects involving African communities in sustainable
development, like re-forestation, bring new revenue into those
communities. People who have been pitied and recipients of aid now
have the power to create a foundation for a sustainable future and
become architects of their own destinies.
There are also traces of trading in concepts. The
world is in a transitional state from transacting in physical assets
to intangible assets – social capital, concepts, knowledge, and
others. We see platforms like Innovation Exchange on which people
get paid by major companies for the best innovative idea and social
currency, but it is a very fragmented landscape. In order for this
to explode, the value in ideas must be as easy to quantify and
exchange as cash.
Imagine anyone in Africa, or anywhere, who has an
innovative idea that someone finds of value can get paid in a
transactional currency. This is a transformation of the principle of
bartering, which is only a shadow of what this could be.
I have been pondering this problem for a long time.
As an entrepreneur myself, there is always the continual struggle to
get sufficient capital to establish and grow a new venture, which is
our core business. Having gone through the creation of several
brands, we have developed a process for transforming ideas into
tangible, profitable ventures. Yet, we have hundreds of ideas that
are useful solutions for different markets that we cannot develop
because of capacity tied to the amount of resources we have
available. In this new paradigm, we would be paid for these ideas,
increasing our wealth and providing additional capital to the
ventures we want to develop.
Some consider this a little far-fetched, so I
haven’t written about it until this time. Everything changed when I
read, "Opportunism: How to Change the World – One Idea at a Time,"
by Shraga Biran. For the first time, I see a framework that could be
executed from a policy and structural level, which means that
implementation can follow. He says of this emerging economic
paradigm, "value of an opportunity is so great that it must be
understood as a positive asset – not a means to create wealth but a
form of wealth in itself."
When we are speaking of an economy based on ideas,
however, it is not about vague or broad ideas for the most part. It
is focused around an opportunity. Opportunity is something that
someone sees that others have overlooked and make it something of
value. In business and to me, this represents a sustainable business
model which provides value to a market and for which they are
willing to pay. It is putting pieces together so that the sum of the
pieces is greater than the individual pieces (and something that can
be leveraged to do more).
To a great degree, this type of economy cannot exist
until many people in a society see themselves as creators instead of
just workers. According to Biran, "…a creator uses his human
capital: the accumulation of individual intelligence, education,
expertise, and imagination to discover or create wealth. This person
cannot be replaced, but can be assisted by new knowledge
industries."
While not at full thrust, the shift is beginning to
occur with African youth. In a small study of African international
students in the United States, many whose parents became successful
professionals but still with moderate means, express their desire to
become entrepreneurs and go back to Africa to make a difference.
They want to develop wealth for themselves and for others.
And finally, if this is the seed of the African
youth generation, this means they will be able to multiple the
wealth on the continent in infinite ways that could never have been
conceived before this generation. Biran summarizes how this can be
done very well, "The shift from physical to intellectual property as
a growing component in the economy also creates an almost infinite
source of dynamism, because – unlike natural resources such as
fossil fuels, newly opened prairie, or even the grains of sand that
are processed into silicon chips – the human intellect never runs
out."
What does all of this have to do with business in
Africa? If firms do not capture these waves of change, they will
find themselves left behind on the continent.
By Lauri Elliott, Source: Afribiz