Choosing a cartridge with too little Terminal
Medicine could result in a severely wounded animal suffering
unnecessarily for hours, weeks or years. No hunter wants to be
responsible for such suffering.
There have been many formulas to help hunters select
a cartridge for specific game animals. Some have been accepted and
others have been ignored. No previous formula has ever been
successful in aiding cartridge selection across the full gamut of
game that the world offers to human hunters.
Usually the great failing of such formulas has been
addressing the gigantic game animals. Hippopotamus and rhinoceros
are huge, to be sure, but elephants are gigantic.
|

Scale is everything. 303 British,
9.3x74R, and 470 Nitro Express cartridges |
The Terminal Medicine formula was developed
specifically to aid in the selection of bullets and cartridges to be
used in the sporting pursuit of gigantic creatures. Not just giant
game animals like elephants, but even giant predators. After all,
elephants can become quite predatory at times. When this behaviour
presents itself, the amount of Terminal Medicine required for a
successful hunt increases.
A large bull elephant can be as imposing a threat as
an average size Tyrannosaurs rex might have been. Most people would
approach a hunt differently if they considered that a rogue or
murderous bull elephant posses as great a threat as a T. rex.
It is always better to overestimate ones foe than to
face the disaster that can result from underestimating one.
If you treat every bull elephant as if it were a
predator of equal size and weight, no elephant will ever catch you
underestimating him.
And if some resourceful fellow ever does bring
Tyrannosaurus rex back to our world you will not underestimate it
and go gallivanting off to save the world with an M-16 only to
discover what the inside of a T. rex mouth looks, smells and
feels like.
Adequate weapon selection is always important; the
situation and the game dictate the necessary armament. An M-16 might
not be appropriate for the stalking of a T. rex but one would be a
good choice if stalking a platoon of armed rebel soldiers.
|
 |
|
T.Rx Game
Values Table by Weight. Recommended T.Rx cartridge values
for Game and Predators based on weight. Green values are for
game animals; black values are for predators of the same
weight |
To be adequately armed for the sporting pursuit of a
typical six ton bull elephant whose behaviour has turned predatory
the Terminal Medicine formula (abbreviated: T.Rx) suggests
cartridges with a T.Rx value of 81 or higher. Cartridges such as the
450 to 470 Nitro Express group (T.Rx range: 81-85) meet this
criteria. Interestingly enough, so does the 8-bore rifle firing a
brass cased 875gr. round ball at 1,650fps (T.Rx 83).
|

Images of various Bullet Impact
Zone (BIZ) types. 303 British FMJ, 9.3x74R Jacketed
Solid, 458 Lott Woodleigh Jacketed Solid - rounded BIZ,
458 Lott A-square monolithic solid – semi-spherical BIZ,
458 Lott Barnes monolithic solid – wide meplat BIZ, 470
Nitro Express Barnes monolithic solid, 470 Capstick
Barnes monolithic solid – wide meplat BIZ, 470 Capstick
A-square monolithic solid – semi-spherical BIZ, 470
Capstick Woodleigh Jacketed Solid – rounded BIZ |
Never before have we had the means to be able to
accurately compare the effectiveness of a classic bore-rifle firing
a lead ball to the cartridge rifles firing jacketed bullets that
replaced it. Yet hunters from the turn of the nineteenth to the
twentieth centuries told us that these cartridges were comparable
based on experience.
Most hunters of that era switched to the deeply
penetrating 450 to 470 group of cartridges right out. That those
cartridges were lighter weight and less voluminous than their
bore-rifle counterparts certainly helped as this allowed for a
greater number of cartridges without increasing the weight to be
carried. More cartridges meant more game and that meant more profit.
It was a simple decision really.
Still, some hunters did not make the switch. Some
did not feel that the new hot-burning smokeless propellants required
to push the little jacketed bullets fast enough to equal the
effectiveness of a trusted black powder 8-bore rifle with which they
had already had such great success was really worth it. Many hunters
used such bore-rifles well into the smokeless era, with great
success I might add.
|

Similarly constructed monolithic
solids, but note the Bullet Impact Zone (BIZ) is
significantly different. The A-square bullet on the left
has a semi-spherical BIZ whereas the Barnes bullet on
the right has a wide meplat BIZ. Changes in BIZ
measurably impact effectiveness. |
Terminal Medicine was developed to aid in the
selection of cartridges and bullets for the giant creatures, but
surprisingly, the Terminal Medicine formula seems to work when
selecting bullets and cartridges for game of all sizes and scales;
for predators and game alike.
Some examples of Terminal Medicine suggested values
and cartridges are illustrated below:
To be adequately armed for a 140 pound deer (T.Rx
29-37) the formula recommends cartridges such as .243 Winchester (T.Rx
29), 450 Black Powder Express deer load (T.Rx 33) or .303 British (T.Rx
36).
Turn that deer into a 140 pound predator, say a
Leopard, (T.Rx 42-50) and the formula suggests for adequate armament
such cartridges as .308 Winchester (T.Rx 42), 12-bore Paradox lead
ball load (T.Rx 46) or 9.3x62 Mauser (T.Rx 50).
The Terminal Medicine requirements for game are
lower than for predators, thus the T.Rx range for the Leopard is
also adequate for a much larger game animal, such as a 625 pound
elk. This emphasizes the need to differentiate between game and
predator when choosing a bullet/cartridge combination.
|

T.Rx Cartridge Values Table. This
table provides examples of various cartridges listed in
the article and their associated T.Rx values |
If
that 625 pound beast is a tiger (T.Rx 55-63) then the bar is raised
again. The Terminal Medicine formula suggests that adequate armament
for such a tiger includes some legendary cartridges: 9.3x74R (T.Rx
56), 375 Holland & Holland Flanged Magnum (T.Rx 60) and 375 Holland
& Holland Belted Magnum (T.Rx 63).
These few examples clearly demonstrate how the
Terminal Medicine formula can be used to aid a hunter in the
selection of an adequate rifle cartridge and bullet for the game to
be pursued. It offers clear and accurate guidance whether selecting
a rifle to stalk that tasty white tail deer out on the back forty or
when preparing to stalk a murderous lion or elephant that is
terrorizing an otherwise peaceful village.
As a final thought, it is important to remember that
the Terminal Medicine formula is calculated using solid or jacketed
bullets because the terminal performance characteristics of
expanding bullets is, from the moment of impact onward, a fluid,
changing and unpredictable data set.
This does not indicate that the formula is of no use
when the hunter intends to select an expanding bullet for a hunt.
Provided the expanding bullet has adequate penetration
characteristics for the intended game it can simply be said that the
expanding bullet will perform at least as well as a jacketed or
solid bullet where all other measures are the same (calibre, bullet
weight, bullet speed, etc.). It is quite likely that it will perform
better.
Hunters must beware unrealistic expectations and
overestimation of bullet performance. The awesome power of Thor’s
hammer, to strike an opponent instantly dead, has yet to be
replicated. If the "magic" expanding bullet fails to perform as
claimed then the resulting effect on the game animal will be quite
similar to that of a jacketed or solid bullet. To know that the
cartridge and bullet chosen are enough, even in such a circumstance,
is critical to a successful hunt and the hunter’s peace of mind.
The Terminal Medicine formula is much too
complicated and involved to explore in depth in such limited space.
To learn more about the T.Rx formula and how to use it to select a
Minimum, Adequate, Proper, Improved, Superior or Stopping rifle and
cartridge please consult the book rexGun (by Dr. Stephen W.
Templar; Ivory Lady Publishing 2008; ISBN: 978-0-615-22413-8).
Dr. Stephen W. Templar